Forums Forums National News Rail companies ban e-cigarettes from trains

Rail companies ban e-cigarettes from trains and stations.

Source : click me

Where next ?

its getting ridiculous. I use an ecig... been 9 weeks since i lit a ciggy, in fact ive not lit one since i started with the ecig

the governments around the world are only complaining cos they cant tax it.....YET and the loss of sales to the tobacco industry
is phenominal

I don't understand why people would feel uneasy. However, I don't think ecigs should be smoked where real fags cannot. I also think that it is codswallop that not being able to smoke an ecig (on a train) would drive people back to smoking.

I don't smoke, can't stand the things, but the e-cigs seemed like a good idea for those that need their fix.

Like jabber, one of the guys who started using one of these several weeks ago (and then talked me into stocking them) hasn't had a proper cigarette since.

Some of the flavours they come in can smell a bit strong (especially the chocolate ones) but if you have to start banning smells theirs a few things that would come higher up the list.

I don't think that banning them on trains will drive people back to proper cigarettes, as you can't use those on trains either.

It's only certain companies that have banned them, and none of those are in the North West, so maybe we'll see if it appears here or is revoked there.

Interestingly the ban would be company policy, not a legal requirement, so how any penalty would be enforced should be interesting.

fooking smokers deserve everything they get.

Same with drinkers & druggies!!

The trouble is, smokers generate roughly £10bn in taxes per year. If nobody smoked, that revenue would have to come from somewhere else. That means increased taxes for people who work, higher prices on petrol, food (yes some is taxed) etc.

IF you work, would you be happy to pay a lot more tax just so cigarettes didn't exist? The health issues of smokers would still be there so the price they cost the NHS (roughly £1.6bn) would still have to be found.

Alcohol causes more health problems, not to mention violence, drink driving etc. Maybe it should be treated the same way. Same with fatty foods, high calorie sweet foods etc, as obesity is a problem. You could go on and on banning stuff.

The Government should ban everything, its for the best.

Seriously though, I dont want my child seeing someone smoke a 'fake' cigarrette and think its cool.

All smoking should be banned in public places, even outdoor. If im in town and some dirty fag hag with yellowed teeth and reeking breath exhales her rancid smoke into my path, it ruins my day.

i agree with this, should treat them like real fags..if you can't smoke in that area..then e-cigs shouldn't be allowed either...

i gave up 24 weeks ago,
but used champix as didn't want any nicotine...

good luck tho to all those trying :-)

MERSEYRAIL say e-cigarettes could be banned on trains as they review their policies.

It comes as train operators C2C, Greater Anglia and First Capital Connect bring in new rules which stop passengers from using the nicotine devices onboard.

Merseyrail have now said that they are looking at passengers’ views on the devices and may follow suit.

Source
A spokeswoman said: “Merseyrail closely monitors the views of our customers regarding the smoking of tobacco and e-cigarettes on trains and stations and we are currently reviewing our policies.

"Should we conclude that there is a case for outlawing it, we would take the necessary steps to do so.”

Almost 1.5m Britons now use the e-cigarettes, which resemble traditional cigarettes, to help them overcome their addiction to tobacco, but the rail companies insist some varieties still expel nicotine, and can make other passengers feel uneasy.

A Greater Anglia rail spokesman said: “In common with other train operators we have recently taken the decision to include cigarettes in the smoking ban on our trains and stations.

“This decision is in line with the British Medical Association’s recommendation that e-cigarettes should be included in the ban on smoking in public places.”

But Amanda Standford, a spokesman for the antismoking group ASH described the ban as “unhelpful” and warned that it could drive many people trying to kick the habit with the fake cigarettes back to tobacco use.

Last week it emerged that Transport for London, which runs the capital’s public transport network, is also considering a ban.

The e-cigarettes are already banned from J D Wetherspoon pubs.

Ban with no just cause, stupid fascist state.

The only thing I don't like about e-cigs is the way people wear them around their neck. Did you make a necklace of 20 B&H when you smoked proper fags?

Fascist is correct
The vapour is harming nobody else, only the user
Its only because it looks like a fag that it bothers people
I don't like the way some people dress but It does not mean they should be banned from wearing it
Damn it, I don't like some food people eat so why not ban that as well
In fact ban everything I don't like, lol
If we all liked and hated the same things the world would be a boring place

It all depends what's in that vapour.



And the BMA says:



The French have done a study and they claim:

And some more about the harmless "water vapour" that comes off them:




and:

Aaaahhh! that lovely glycerine and propylene glycol vapour