WikiWirral Wirral's Biggest Online Forum
Forum Stats
12285 Members
65 Forums
73046 Topics
985438 Posts
32 posts in the last 24hrs
Max Online: 7831 @ 8th Apr 2013 4:18pm
Who's Online - Click Me
69 registered (11kendo, 16 invisible), 1547 Guests and 254 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Social Media : Follow Us


(Views 7days)This Weeks Most Read
Garden Waste Bins 466
New Brighton Big Wheel 395
How worried should we be? 381
Homing Pigeon 331
Rock Lane West Crash - Road Closed 278
The Durrells 273
Little Boy Blue 271
Might have changed my mind re death penalty. 264
Freemasonry unwrapped 232
Whitehall shut down 205
New General Forums
Dreams
by granny
12:27 PM
Death penalty --to Paradise !
by venice
26th Apr 2017 12:54pm
Tory manifesto for the NHS
by casper
26th Apr 2017 11:06am
Fakes Docs
by snowshoes
25th Apr 2017 12:27am
New Wirral History
STREET MAPS
by Paternoster21
22nd Apr 2017 10:54am
Historic tours of Ellesmere Port
by Paternoster21
22nd Apr 2017 7:53am
whetstone lane boxing club
by oldbirkonian1
19th Apr 2017 6:34pm
Where was Wirral underground munitions factory?
by yoller
19th Apr 2017 10:01am
Memories or the chronicles of Birkenhead - Gamlin
by derekdwc
13th Apr 2017 12:03pm
Forum Tips
Photo Gallery Forums
New Brighton Big Wheel
Birkenhead Transport Museum 24th Feb 2017
Topic Replies
Might have changed my mind re death penalty.
by lincle
April Photo Competition
by granny
06:50 PM
Residents Social Club Duke Street
by _Ste_
06:01 PM
For Sale Single Folding Guest Bed
by Heidi123
01:06 PM
zgemma box for sale
by stumpyduck
01:02 PM
vu+duo for sale
by stumpyduck
01:00 PM
Windows 10 latest "Creators" Update
by MikeT
11:30 AM
Motorola Moto E3 smartphones, new and boxed, Black
by gerrymoore
09:11 AM
Garden Waste Bins
by Beethoven
08:37 AM
April
M Tu W Th F Sa Su
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Recent Posts : What's On ?
Gawthorpe Hall
by diggingdeeper
26th Apr 2017 3:16pm
Dunham Massey
by techgran
14th Apr 2017 12:57pm
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#1030453 - 10th Feb 2017 9:53am Hospital
cools Offline
Forum Addict

Registered: 16th Aug 2013
Posts: 1694
Loc: Wirral
Anyone else watch Hospital which was on TV other night? If you did what are your thoughts on 98 year old man having heart op and a part transplanted to help him walk and get about better.During op he had a blood clot happen which had to be removed from his brain. Now he did come through it all but to me and it might be abit controversial but I thought that's being greedy for life. It all cost over 30,000 and the surgeon said it would cost more than that it he were to come in with stroke or heart trouble and have to stay in hospital. Sorry but I think we all want to live as long as we can but just because it's possible with intervention is it right to go against the aging process? I don't know maybe I'm totally wrong in my thinking be interested in your thoughts on subject.

Top
Google Ads
#1030459 - 10th Feb 2017 10:48am Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
fish5133 Online   content
Forum Master

Registered: 22nd Mar 2010
Posts: 2917
Loc: Heswallish
Not agreeing or disagreeing with you cools. I suppose its real life training for the surgeons and gives them experience and knowledge for when they treat younger people. If the old guys been working all his life and paying taxes and NI then why not. Who decides what age you can longer get treated?
We are told it cost 30,000 but some if not most of cost is still there even if he wasn't treated. Surgeons and nurses get paid annually for doing their job.
Debateable that heart problems is due to ageing process and not lifestyle choices.

Top
#1030471 - 10th Feb 2017 1:49pm Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
lincle Online   content
Enthusiast

Registered: 30th Jan 2014
Posts: 185
Loc: wirral
I watched the programme , It was said at one point that years ago the op wouldnt have taken place on a 98 year old.The probability of a stroke during the op was very high & did in fact happen so he was transferred to another hospital for more surgery. At his age I expect he served during the war,paid his dues & has a loving family BUT if the brain op hadnt removed the clot he would have spent whats left of his life in care,maybe unable to function.I dont think many of us would want to take the risks so respect to the gentleman involved even though it cost the NHS thousands .Im on the fence with this one as I have a DNR in place & no-one lives forever.

Top
#1030498 - 10th Feb 2017 6:59pm Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
diggingdeeper Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 9th Jul 2008
Posts: 10002
Loc: Birkenhead
Its all valuable research, one of the main problems of surgery is the reduction and identification of clots that develop during surgery, new techniques are being found all the time.

If people volunteer as guinea pigs then that is their choice.
_________________________
In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell

When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser. Socrates

Top
#1030500 - 10th Feb 2017 7:33pm Re: Hospital [Re: diggingdeeper]
lincle Online   content
Enthusiast

Registered: 30th Jan 2014
Posts: 185
Loc: wirral
Agreed Digger but in this case the Gentleman didn't offer himself as a Guinea Pig he just wanted to live longer & that's his choice to make

Top
#1030503 - 10th Feb 2017 9:04pm Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
diggingdeeper Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 9th Jul 2008
Posts: 10002
Loc: Birkenhead
Guinea pigs always have a reason, he will have been made very well aware that he might be curtailing his life, not lengthening it.
_________________________
In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell

When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser. Socrates

Top
#1030516 - 10th Feb 2017 11:44pm Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
venice Offline

Forum Master

Registered: 21st Jul 2011
Posts: 2685
Loc: Wirral
My thoughts are that its unlikely any of us know for sure what the motivation for operating was . It could have been to keep him going for a year or two purely because he was otherwise fit and as someone said , hed paid his dues , or it could be it suited the medical teams to have a bit of practice , as suggested .

I agree wholeheartedly with reason 2 -- with reason 1 , I have mixed feelings .We dont like to think of the worth of a life measured in money , and thats what privatization will do , but in the case of the very elderly , it wouldnt surprise me if in the future we have to save to take out pecific extra 'life extension' insurance if we wish to have expensive surgery , after say 90 or so .

Of course in an ideal world, there would be enough NHS money to pay for everything, but its not going to happen , so we will have to make hard decisions .

Top
#1030518 - 11th Feb 2017 12:09am Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
diggingdeeper Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 9th Jul 2008
Posts: 10002
Loc: Birkenhead
If there are hard choices to be made should it not be based on how well the person has attempted to look after their health and well being together with ability/inability to afford?

Someone that is still playing tennis into their nineties should not be penalised, someone that has been a slob most of their lives and costed the NHS a lot because of that should not be treated as an equal.

Or .... no bias at all. The biggest bias in recent years has been the question of "can we keep this person alive for 10 years" and seems to be a target in many medical cases. To write someone off at 66 because they are unlikely to reach 76 is wrong, most of these people have worked most of their lives and contributed to society, they are entitled to the time of leisure. I can understand a lower setting but my opinion is that if they are likely to have anything over 6 months of quality life then that fully justifies their entitlement.

The biggest problem is the lack of investment by the government in training new nurses and doctors, they face a situation of the employees ruling the roost because of the supply/demand situation.

Another area the government has failed in is controlling the medical profession, medical professionals play with peoples lives after long hours where they would not be allowed to drive or operate machinery with those hours.

I also believe that a person has a right to die of their own choice provided it can be demonstrated that their quality of life is below, and likely to remain below, what they consider reasonable.
_________________________
In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell

When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser. Socrates

Top
#1030523 - 11th Feb 2017 2:54am Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
venice Offline

Forum Master

Registered: 21st Jul 2011
Posts: 2685
Loc: Wirral
I dont think it should be judged on how well people have looked after themselves alongside financial considerations, because it would be too hard to judge fairly.

The person fostering 2 children one of whom is disabled , with a dementia struck parent to oversee may have no time to prioritise exercise and their own healthcare.

What about the person who is just born with less oomph and doesnt have the energy or drive to exercise ?

What about the person who is unable to control their food intake because cuts mean clinical help is unavailable and they have no willpower ?(latest studies show some people's physiology makes it harder)

How about the person living in group type accommodation where they are not in control of the kinds of food being served most of the time and money is short-?

How about people who are over the 'poverty level' but are helping out an offspring in dire straits and therefore cut back on their own normally healthy lifestyle, to do so ?

What about people who are depressed and comfort eat ?

What about those who are workaholics who run themselves into the ground despite eating well?

How do you judge eligibility of people who have lived healthily for half their lives but not the the other half for whatever reason .

How do you even prove who has looked after themselves and who hasnt ? Some people who are naturally slim , do no exercise, and look as if theyve lived super healthily -- but havent ?

What about your dangerous sport addicts - who judges if they have looked after their health well when many of them will have needed hospital care which wouldnt have been needed if they hadnt been boxing, skiing ,showjumping , climbing or whatever?

I wouldnt like to be the on the panel who has to decide which of the above are more worthy of receiving treatment than another . I just dont see how it could be worked out at all, because you're comparing
such vastly different things with too many variants and unknowns.

So, for me you treat everyone regardless of how theyve looked after themselves . As I said, though if ruthless cuts DO have to be made, I think the over 90's or 95's (regardless of how theyve looked after themselves) would be the group likely to be targeted by the NHS , because its easier to justify limiting expensive treatments to them, than any other groups I can think of.

Mind you , thats objective. If it was my husband, mum or dad , I would probably be fighting to get them treated .

Agree with all the other points you made DD . A legal self destruct button like fish advocated a bit back, would be my preference for choosing the time of ones demise.

Top
#1030527 - 11th Feb 2017 4:22am Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
diggingdeeper Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 9th Jul 2008
Posts: 10002
Loc: Birkenhead
An excellent reply Venice clap

Nobody has the right to play God with anybody else's life and certainly not with any predefined conditions.
_________________________
In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell

When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser. Socrates

Top
#1030533 - 11th Feb 2017 11:18am Re: Hospital [Re: diggingdeeper]
venice Offline

Forum Master

Registered: 21st Jul 2011
Posts: 2685
Loc: Wirral

Quote DD "Nobody has the right to play God with anybody else's life and certainly not with any predefined conditions.[/quote]

Not ever? Even mercy killings? Soldier in the field leaving behind his critically wounded mate to the ministrations of oncoming ISIS ?

Spouse who's COPD motor neurone partner begs and begs and begs because they can no longer cope with the suffocation feeling and excruciating pain ?(Bearing in mind medics DONT/CANT always give legal relief)


Top
#1030535 - 11th Feb 2017 12:04pm Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
cools Offline
Forum Addict

Registered: 16th Aug 2013
Posts: 1694
Loc: Wirral
Yes it's a hard one to say ye or nay too really suppose it's personal choice of whether you want to live longer and the quality of your life. Don't you think the medical profession have taken over the decision of God and really as has been quoted become a victim of its own success! At one time you were only expected to reach 3score years 10. I'm glad for my sake that now people are living alot longer but doubt whether I will reach 98/100 as people do regularly these days , would I want to? I guess none of us can answer that until we have to, I know unless I had quality of life the answer would be no.

Top
#1030542 - 11th Feb 2017 2:39pm Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
venice Offline

Forum Master

Registered: 21st Jul 2011
Posts: 2685
Loc: Wirral
How many people would pay into a new 'extended life fund' I wonder , if it was brought out (separate from private medical care)to ensure they would be treated after about 90yrs old. Going by pensions, not many is my guess , as few trust the Govt enough to be assured their money wont end up in the Govt's 'we changed our rules fund'

Top
#1030563 - 11th Feb 2017 6:39pm Re: Hospital [Re: venice]
diggingdeeper Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 9th Jul 2008
Posts: 10002
Loc: Birkenhead
Originally Posted By: venice
How many people would pay into a new 'extended life fund' I wonder , if it was brought out (separate from private medical care)to ensure they would be treated after about 90yrs old. Going by pensions, not many is my guess , as few trust the Govt enough to be assured their money wont end up in the Govt's 'we changed our rules fund'


Anybody can do this already with either private treatment or health insurance provided the theatre team think it is not too high a risk but being private (kerching!) the risk goalposts may change a bit from NHS.
_________________________
In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell

When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser. Socrates

Top
#1030623 - 12th Feb 2017 6:08pm Re: Hospital [Re: cools]
RUDEBOX Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 29th Aug 2008
Posts: 19090
Loc: Bob Land
_________________________
Mia Mabel


Top

Moderator:  Mod 
Random Wirral Images

Click to View Topic.
Newest Topics
Might have changed my mind re death penalty.
by venice
28th Apr 2017 6:18pm
Carpet Fitter
by JaseB
28th Apr 2017 12:03pm
Garden Waste Bins
by granny
27th Apr 2017 10:55am
Ribes
by locomotive
26th Apr 2017 9:16pm
Rock Lane West Crash - Road Closed
by diggingdeeper
26th Apr 2017 3:10pm
For Sale & Free
For Sale Single Folding Guest Bed
by Heidi123
01:06 PM
zgemma box for sale
by stumpyduck
01:02 PM
Motorola Moto E3 smartphones, new and boxed, Black
by gerrymoore
09:11 AM
Brownie Uniform Age 8 or 9
by Giggler
28th Apr 2017 7:21pm
Maxi Cosi Tobi car seat 30
by Greenwood
27th Apr 2017 11:01pm
Featured Member
Registered: 18th Nov 2014
Posts: 429
Newest Members
BritSol, errynbeattie, loubie343, windsail, Hollyange
12285 Registered Users
Today's Birthdays
Tanzi (50)
New Wirral Info
Carpet Fitter
by JaseB
28th Apr 2017 12:03pm
Garden Waste Bins
by granny
27th Apr 2017 10:55am
Homing Pigeon
by rossie
25th Apr 2017 10:23am
Gawthorpe Hall
by diggingdeeper
25th Apr 2017 12:28am
Freemasonry unwrapped
by Tait1969
24th Apr 2017 8:21pm
News : New Topics
Whitehall shut down
by eddtheduck
27th Apr 2017 5:42pm
Rock Lane West Crash - Road Closed
by diggingdeeper
26th Apr 2017 3:10pm
How worried should we be?
by venice
26th Apr 2017 8:35am
New Brighton Big Wheel
by cools
23rd Apr 2017 9:29pm
Found - cycle computer / speedo
by philmch
23rd Apr 2017 1:35pm
New Enthusiast Forums
Might have changed my mind re death penalty.
by venice
28th Apr 2017 6:18pm
Ribes
by locomotive
26th Apr 2017 9:16pm
Little Boy Blue
by cools
24th Apr 2017 6:58pm
The Durrells
by granny
23rd Apr 2017 6:39pm
Windows 10 latest "Creators" Update
by diggingdeeper
22nd Apr 2017 6:36pm
(Views 24hrs)Trending Newest Topics
Dreams 32
Wirral Sunrise Sunset
Sunrise Sun 5:37am
Sunset Sun 8:41pm
Local Time Sun 9:52am
WikiWirral Can . . . .