Our Success is in our members who value our strength as a valued community.
Forum Statistics
Posts1,014,187
Topics74,850
Members12,887
Forums66
Posts in last 24hrs30
Most Online7,831
Apr 8th, 2013
Who's Online Now
52 registered members (11kendo, 9 invisible), 1,175 guests, and306 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Social Media : Follow Us


Popular Topics(Views 7days)
70 Wheel
New General Forums
Serious Bit of Kit
by diggingdeeper. 21st Feb 2019 2:17pm
Gaza strip
by venice. 17th Feb 2019 1:30am
ISIS
by casper. 14th Feb 2019 9:32am
Join Us Tonight .. FREE ENTRY ..
by WargamerNik. 13th Feb 2019 12:29pm
New Wirral History
Vikings, Wirral
by granny. 21st Feb 2019 11:26am
Finding Information about Leslie John Robinson.
by Kaylawritinglife. 18th Feb 2019 10:34pm
Morpeth Buildings Brook St
by Ducko. 12th Jan 2009 11:39am
Forum Tips
Photo Gallery Forums
WW1 Monument, Birkenhead
No more bridge, never be the same
Topic Replies
Dispose of old laptop
by moretonjeffo. 21st Feb 2019 5:18pm
New Brighton stick car racing?
by johncon. 21st Feb 2019 4:01pm
Dispose of old laptop
by johncon. 21st Feb 2019 3:44pm
Huge Tide
by diggingdeeper. 21st Feb 2019 2:00pm
Vikings, Wirral
by granny. 21st Feb 2019 11:45am
What are you currently reading?
by missmahjong. 21st Feb 2019 10:33am
6900 New Jobs Wirral west
by diggingdeeper. 21st Feb 2019 10:33am
What song are you listening to?
by starakita. 20th Feb 2019 6:56pm
Egremont Ferry to Be Destroyed
by casper. 20th Feb 2019 9:28am
February
M T W T F S S
1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28
Recent Posts : What's On ?
RAF Tornado Farewell Flypast Tour
by diggingdeeper. 19th Feb 2019 2:29pm
Join Us Tonight .. FREE ENTRY ..
by WargamerNik. 13th Feb 2019 12:30pm
Previous Topic
Next Topic
Print Topic
Rate Topic
Catalan Claims #1046585
28th Oct 2017 8:57am
28th Oct 2017 8:57am
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,627
wirral
E
Excoriator Offline OP
Forum Addict
Excoriator  Offline OP
Forum Addict
E
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,627
wirral
Desperate efforts are being made by Farage, the Torygraph and the potty Express to persuade us that Catalan's rejection of Spain is a rejection of the EU.

It is nothing of the sort of course. Catalan would really love to be part of the EU as an independent nation, although this would be embarrassing to Spain. Should Catalan actually manage to secede, I imagine the EU will not recognise it for about 20 or 30 years when tempers will have cooled to the extent when it will admit Catalonia with Spain's agreement.

It is an internal Spanish dispute, and apart from having to remain on good terms with both sides, nothing to do with the EU. Spain, like all the other members of the EU, is a sovereign nation and will have to handle the dispute as best it can.

Madrid seems to have handled it very badly. They would have been wiser, I think, to allow a non-binding referendum in the region. According to the polls, the 'leavers' - although numerous, are not in the majority.


Google Ads
Re: Catalan Claims [Re: Excoriator] #1046595
28th Oct 2017 6:17pm
28th Oct 2017 6:17pm
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 12,350
Birkenhead
diggingdeeper Offline

Wiki Master
diggingdeeper  Offline

Wiki Master
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 12,350
Birkenhead
Difficult call on the result of a real referendum. It wouldn't be the first poll where people intentionally gave the wrong answer in order to manipulate the situation. If the polls all came back as a definite "no", the Spanish Government might have risked a real referendum.

Now which country did that happen in recently wink


In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell

We should judge our economy by the absence of poverty, not the number of billionaires - Jeremy Corbyn
Re: Catalan Claims [Re: Excoriator] #1046604
29th Oct 2017 10:00am
29th Oct 2017 10:00am
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,627
wirral
E
Excoriator Offline OP
Forum Addict
Excoriator  Offline OP
Forum Addict
E
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,627
wirral
Well, a government doesn't HAVE to follow the result of a referendum.

Cameron's mistake was not to call a referendum, but to promise that the government would follow it's conclusion. We have a parliament to make decisions and get things done, not to run referendums and let the people decide. Had Madrid made it clear that the result was non-binding, I suspect the problem would simply have gone away.

Last edited by Excoriator; 29th Oct 2017 10:02am.
Re: Catalan Claims [Re: Excoriator] #1046611
29th Oct 2017 1:17pm
29th Oct 2017 1:17pm
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 12,350
Birkenhead
diggingdeeper Offline

Wiki Master
diggingdeeper  Offline

Wiki Master
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 12,350
Birkenhead
Originally Posted by Excoriator
Well, a government doesn't HAVE to follow the result of a referendum.

Cameron's mistake was not to call a referendum, but to promise that the government would follow it's conclusion. We have a parliament to make decisions and get things done, not to run referendums and let the people decide. Had Madrid made it clear that the result was non-binding, I suspect the problem would simply have gone away.


You mean the UK Government doesn't have to follow the result of a referendum, this is because we don't have a proper bill of rights so a referendum has no legal status whatsoever.

Many other countries have binding referendums because they are further advanced in democracy than we are. We don't even have the power to de-select an MP never mind how rogue he has become - there is absolutely nothing to stop a candidate pretending to be with one party but voting with another party all the time once he takes his seat.

Spanish law may be different to ours, I believe they do have binding referendums?


In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell

We should judge our economy by the absence of poverty, not the number of billionaires - Jeremy Corbyn
Re: Catalan Claims [Re: diggingdeeper] #1046675
30th Oct 2017 10:02pm
30th Oct 2017 10:02pm
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 12
bromborough
M
mgbsheep Offline
Newbeee
mgbsheep  Offline
Newbeee
M
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 12
bromborough
Originally Posted by diggingdeeper


You mean the UK Government doesn't have to follow the result of a referendum, this is because we don't have a proper bill of rights so a referendum has no legal status whatsoever.


Not quite. We could have had a binding referendum, it's perfectly possible, we had one a few years ago for the alternative vote system.

The key is how the "enabling act" is set up. The for AV referendum it was very specific in the act as to what would happen as a result of more votes being cast in favour of AV than against (https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2011/1/part/1/chapter/2). Clearly defining the winning line and the prize. This was a binding referendum.

The EU referendum was not set up in this way but it could have been. Instead it became advisory or consultative, no winning line, no prize, just advice.

I'd love to point you to the same section of the EU referendum act but it's not there which makes it non-binding.. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/36/contents



Re: Catalan Claims [Re: diggingdeeper] #1046677
30th Oct 2017 10:08pm
30th Oct 2017 10:08pm
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 12
bromborough
M
mgbsheep Offline
Newbeee
mgbsheep  Offline
Newbeee
M
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 12
bromborough
Originally Posted by diggingdeeper

Spanish law may be different to ours, I believe they do have binding referendums?


It is, the spanish constitution lays out the rules and as far as I understand it the catalans would need to get the rest of spain to agree to a referendum and then get a result across the whole of spain. So probably unlikely to get the result the catalan separatists want. (http://idpbarcelona.net/docs/blog/legality_referendum.pdf)

As with most legal things there are elements of interpretation which can be argued either way... or how else would lawyers make money...


Re: Catalan Claims [Re: Excoriator] #1046679
30th Oct 2017 10:12pm
30th Oct 2017 10:12pm
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 12,350
Birkenhead
diggingdeeper Offline

Wiki Master
diggingdeeper  Offline

Wiki Master
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 12,350
Birkenhead
We seem to be saying the roughly the same thing but not necessarily from the same angle.

The Government has the choice of what they do with referendums, the people have no say in it because we do not have a proper bill of rights.

While the Government can chose to have a binding referendum by an act of parliament, they also have the power to repeal.


In a time of universal deceit - telling the truth is a revolutionary act. George Orwell

We should judge our economy by the absence of poverty, not the number of billionaires - Jeremy Corbyn
Re: Catalan Claims [Re: Excoriator] #1046683
30th Oct 2017 10:30pm
30th Oct 2017 10:30pm
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 12
bromborough
M
mgbsheep Offline
Newbeee
mgbsheep  Offline
Newbeee
M
Joined: Jan 2012
Posts: 12
bromborough
ok. I can see that.

I'm not sure the government necessarily get to choose, they are only there at our whim and ultimately have to get anything through a vote which they don't necessarily win.

I'm not a fan of the whip system which means they can try to exert a lot of pressure on MPs to vote in line with their party when the MPs code of conduct specifically says that MPs should, with consideration for their constituents (which covers all of them not only those that voted for them or that are eligible to vote) should always act in the best interests of the country. (https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201516/cmcode/1076/107602.htm#a3)

Nice exchanging views with you. I'm off to bed. Good night.


Moderated by  Mod 

Random Wirral Images

Click to View Topic.
Newest Topics
Dispose of old laptop
by johncon. 21st Feb 2019 3:54pm
Dispose of old laptop
by johncon. 21st Feb 2019 3:44pm
Vikings, Wirral
by granny. 21st Feb 2019 11:26am
Huge Tide
by diggingdeeper. 21st Feb 2019 10:25am
6900 New Jobs Wirral west
by fish5133. 20th Feb 2019 11:49am
For Sale & Free
Wheel
by Thorwalker. 18th Feb 2019 1:10pm
Creative Gigaworks T40 Series II Speakers
by Catsick. 16th Feb 2019 11:18am
HP Envy 13.3 Laptop AD059NA
by Catsick. 16th Feb 2019 11:16am
Shed/Summerhouse Guttering Kit
by Catsick. 16th Feb 2019 11:10am
Member Spotlight
Dilly
Dilly
wallasey
Posts: 8,661
Joined: July 2011
Show All Member Profiles 
Newest Members
TonyB1, Dwynwen, URBen, Kaylawritinglife, Nick_senior
12887 Registered Users
Today's Birthdays
No Birthdays
New Wirral Info
Dispose of old laptop
by johncon. 21st Feb 2019 3:54pm
6900 New Jobs Wirral west
by fish5133. 20th Feb 2019 11:49am
Walrus card
by venice. 19th Feb 2019 3:23am
RAF Tornado Farewell Flypast Tour
by diggingdeeper. 16th Feb 2019 12:36pm
Join Us Tonight .. FREE ENTRY ..
by WargamerNik. 13th Feb 2019 12:30pm
News : New Topics
Huge Tide
by diggingdeeper. 21st Feb 2019 10:25am
Egremont Ferry to Be Destroyed
by diggingdeeper. 19th Feb 2019 3:41pm
School Kids Climate Change Protests
by fish5133. 15th Feb 2019 2:08pm
Brief brown-out in New Ferry
by Excoriator. 11th Feb 2019 10:53pm
Very ill informed distracted youth " protesting "
by svenlock68. 11th Feb 2019 10:30am
New Enthusiast Forums
Dispose of old laptop
by johncon. 21st Feb 2019 3:44pm
European Parliament on now.
by granny. 15th Feb 2019 3:26pm
RIP Gordon Banks
by diggingdeeper. 12th Feb 2019 1:48pm
NAILS IN DOG BISCUITS
by venice. 8th Feb 2019 10:24am
Super Bowl Chilli
by granny. 5th Feb 2019 2:13pm
Popular Topics(Views 24hrs)
Wirral Sunrise Sunset
Sunrise Thu 7:17am
Sunset Thu 5:34pm
Local Time Thu 6:59pm
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.6.1.1