Our Success is in our members who value our strength as a valued community.
Forum Stats
12448 Members
65 Forums
73744 Topics
996706 Posts
66 posts in the last 24hrs
Max Online: 7831 @ 8th Apr 2013 4:18pm
Who's Online - Click Me
80 registered (alan128, 14 invisible), 1160 Guests and 256 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Social Media : Follow Us


(Views 7days)This Weeks Most Read
The EU and us. 865
Insecure sites. 564
What is your Daily Exercise ? 370
Games for children 355
Is this crime against humanity 322
Wanted Wii consul 239
Travelling Bus and Train Which Tickets? 208
Replacement Key Fob casing 202
Anyone read this ? 188
Taltalk Broadband Dying 173
New General Forums
Telephone Caller Alert - they are NOT BT BROADBAND
by Laraine
Yesterday at 06:04 PM
Are you a Mathematician ?
by granny
15th Nov 2017 8:59am
Poor Bruce
by diggingdeeper
15th Nov 2017 1:15am
Charity fishing match
by paul110180
14th Nov 2017 8:03pm
New Wirral History
Downloadable oldwirral pdfs
by derekdwc
9th Oct 2017 12:26pm
Forum Tips
Photo Gallery Forums
clipper yachts arriving for round the world race
Azamara,silouette and balmoral this mornig
Topic Replies
Downloadable oldwirral pdfs
by bert1
39 minutes 33 seconds ago
Games for children
by venice
Today at 01:55 AM
Fitting bathroom lights need help
by diggingdeeper
Today at 01:50 AM
DIY advice needed
by yr20405
Yesterday at 11:23 PM
John Lewis advert
by venice
Yesterday at 09:36 PM
Charity fishing match
by paul110180
Yesterday at 09:29 PM
where to get cheap carpet
by venice
Yesterday at 09:27 PM
Charity fishing match
by paul110180
Yesterday at 09:25 PM
What song are you listening to?
by Dilly
Yesterday at 07:42 PM
November
M Tu W Th F Sa Su
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30
Recent Posts : What's On ?
The Lanterns at Chester Zoo
by granny
16th Nov 2017 1:05pm
bonfire night
by snowhite
3rd Nov 2017 5:40pm
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#655285 - 19th Jan 2012 3:08pm how CAN Sherlock return from the dead?
ResearcherTony Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 28th Nov 2011
Posts: 614
Loc: Wallasey


When the Christmas edition of The Strand Magazine appeared in December 1893, it created a literary sensation the like of which had not been seen before, nor has it since.

‘It is with a heavy heart that I take up my pen,’ are the words with which The Final Problem opened — the words with which Doctor Watson announced that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle had killed off his greatest creation.

Sherlock Holmes was dead — having tumbled to his death from the Reichenbach Falls, locked in a death-struggle with his nemesis Professor Moriarty. The reaction to the great detective’s death was extreme. The Strand Magazine lost 20,000 subscribers — and fans of Holmes took to the streets wearing black armbands

Conan Doyle was less sentimental about Holmes than his admirers: the wild success of Holmes was starting to overshadow the rest of his literary output, and, as he put it: ‘I must save my mind for better things, even if it means I must bury my pocketbook with him.’

But there was international rejoicing when the needs of his pocketbook (in other words bank account), caused him to think again. Eight years later, in 1901, came The Hound Of The Baskervilles, a story set before Holmes’s death.

Conan Doyle then caved in entirely with The Adventure Of The Empty House in 1903. The escapade at the Reichenbach Falls did not, Watson revealed, kill the detective after all. The stage was set for Holmes to appear in as many more stories as Conan Doyle chose to write.

This was one of the earliest instances of a narrative device — a cheat, really — known as ‘retconning’: retrospectively altering the continuity.

Anyone who watched those old Saturday morning cartoon serials will recognise it. At the end of one episode, we see Rocket Man crash into a cliff. In the ‘previously’ section at the beginning of the next, the same footage appears, doctored to show Rocket Man strapped into a parachute and bouncing merrily down to safety.

Retconning is a staple of science fiction and comic-book writing, so it’s fitting that when Sherlock Holmes ‘died’ again in the BBC series on Sunday, he did so under the auspices of a team of brilliant writers familiar with the device — the show was co-created by Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, though Steve Thompson wrote Sunday’s episode — all of whom have worked on the BBC’s Doctor Who.

Dramatic: The writing team have used incredible ingenuity to ramp up the tension in reworked plotlines
So could they convince a telly-savvy, internet-age audience that Holmes was really deceased? They certainly created a magnificent teaser.

We saw, or thought we saw, Sherlock fall to his death from the roof of St Bart’s hospital. Watson rushed towards him, hindered only by a coincidental — or was it? — collision with a cyclist. We saw a pulse taken, blood on the pavement and a body being carted off in an ambulance.

Later, we saw Watson and housekeeper Mrs Hudson: sole mourners at a gravestone marked Sherlock Holmes. Finally, Watson delivered an affecting soliloquy, adapting the lines The Final Problem about ‘the best and the wisest man whom I have ever known’, before turning to walk from the grave.

The camera cut away... and there was the lugubrious face of Sherlock actor Benedict Cumberbatch, looking secretly on.

Holmes is alive! But how?

Instead of breaking out the black armbands this time, the online world and the water coolers of offices are fizzing with elaborate and ingenious theories as to how he survived.

Popular hero: Writer Arthur Conan Doyle said he had never been as sentimental over his much-loved characters as the readers
Did Holmes’s friend Molly, the pathologist, supply a Sherlock-sized corpse to be tossed off the building?

Did Sherlock drug himself to stop his own heart? Did brother Mycroft co-ordinate it from his position at the heart of the secret service?

The frenzied debate is nothing new. This sort of speculation has been going on ever since Conan Doyle’s Holmes went over the Falls.

American author Leslie S. Klinger’s scholarly edition, The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes, identifies several schools of thought about The Final Problem in which Holmes and Moriarty supposedly meet their end: Moriarty is imaginary, Moriarty is innocent, Moriarty lives — as well as ‘the fundamentalist school, which accepts that Holmes indeed died at the Falls’.

More than one of these schools of thought was teasingly courted in Sunday’s episode. One of the greatest virtues of the modern BBC Sherlock is how silkily it modernises the stories, while remaining true to the spirit of Holmes.

There’s an affectionately playful relationship between these stories and their originals.

Emotional: Watson, played by Martin Freeman, gives a moving speech at Holmes's grave - but all is not as it seems
The deerstalker hat — a feature of Sidney Paget’s illustrations, as all Holmesians know, rather than Conan Doyle’s text — is similarly treated as an in-joke in the TV version: an impromptu shot of Sherlock in a borrowed deerstalker becomes the stock Press image, much to his irritation.
And Watson uses a blog to report his friend’s doings, rather than writing for The Strand Magazine.

The spirit of their friendship has also been perfectly preserved. Theirs is a chaste fraternal romance. Conan Doyle is said to have described Holmes as being ‘as inhuman’ as the calculating machine envisioned by Victorian inventor Charles Babbage — ‘and just about as likely to fall in love’.

In the new Sherlock, as in the old, Holmes’s regard for the only woman who ever bests him, dominatrix Irene Adler, is a thing of the mind. But more important is the approach that the new Sherlock takes to detection.

Here we glory in the actions of that calculating machine: the brain that can deduce a career path from the shape of a bowler hat or the re-hemming work on a skirt; and can pinpoint a sweet factory in Addlestone from chemical traces in a bootprint.

Those who have complained that Cumberbatch’s Sherlock makes ‘unfair’ deductions the rest of us can’t — that what he does is, effectively, magic — have forgotten Conan Doyle’s original: it was later detective writers who insisted the clues should all be available to the reader. The pleasure is in the ingenuity of his inferences, more than the attempt to compete with him.

In the BBC series, what the plodding policeman, Detective Inspector Lestrade, drily calls ‘CSI Baker Street’ comes as a blessed relief in an age in which — for the sake of ‘grittiness’ — most television detectives now track down their quarries by dismantling the bodies of their victims.

Poignant ending: But what will come next for the story's fresh legion of fans?
Those lazily psycho-sexual serial killers, their motivations as gross and dull as the means of their detection, give little challenge to their audience.

Sherlock’s plots look back to the golden age detective stories that were Holmes’s legacy — when the highest achievement was a ‘locked-room’ murder mystery with few clues.

Conan Doyle’s The Adventure Of The Speckled Band — where a poisonous snake slithers in through a vent and out up a bell-rope, having done its work — is a classic of the genre.

When Moffat’s Sherlock has a man, distracted by a car backfiring, killed by his own flying boomerang, that is a witty sort of locked-room mystery itself: one in the open air.

The guessing games as to how Sherlock engineered his ‘death’ on Sunday night, and whether Moriarty — apparently having shot himself — also survived, will continue for months as we bide away the agonising wait for the next series.

Will it begin with An Adventure Of The Empty House, with Holmes surprising Watson and solving a locked-room mystery? I’d like to think so.

But all we can say for sure is, like Conan Doyle fishing Sherlock out of the Falls, Moffat and Gatiss can take him anywhere they jolly well want
_________________________
the truth is out there

Top
Google Ads
#655287 - 19th Jan 2012 3:09pm Re: how CAN Sherlock return from the dead? [Re: ResearcherTony]
ResearcherTony Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 28th Nov 2011
Posts: 614
Loc: Wallasey
my personal opinion is that, sherlock put his coat on moriarty and through him off the building and got molly to fake the dna results, with watson getting knocked to the ground he never really sore sherlocks body properly.
_________________________
the truth is out there

Top
#655306 - 19th Jan 2012 4:16pm Re: how CAN Sherlock return from the dead? [Re: ResearcherTony]
PaulWirral
Unregistered


Remember the 'favour' he asked Molly?

Say no more... (hint hint)

Top
#655307 - 19th Jan 2012 4:19pm Re: how CAN Sherlock return from the dead? [Re: ]
ResearcherTony Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 28th Nov 2011
Posts: 614
Loc: Wallasey
Originally Posted By: PaulWirral
Remember the 'favour' he asked Molly?

Say no more... (hint hint)


yes thats what makes it so obvious she obviously decleares him dead and id's the body etc and probs manipulates the dna.
_________________________
the truth is out there

Top
#655783 - 20th Jan 2012 2:55pm Re: how CAN Sherlock return from the dead? [Re: ResearcherTony]
GrandMasterFlash Offline
Forum Master

Registered: 12th May 2010
Posts: 2492
Loc: at a computer
Aww but Martin Freeman talking to his grave at the end where he says 'just don't do this, stop it now', so sad!

Same thing happened in the second film, the Robert Downey Jr one, but it was more comical, love Sherlock Holmes laugh

Top
#662459 - 4th Feb 2012 12:38pm Re: how CAN Sherlock return from the dead? [Re: ResearcherTony]
MattLFC Offline
Wiki Master

Registered: 14th Aug 2004
Posts: 22315
Loc: Moreton/Beirut/Mobile
Well if dirty Den managed to arise from the dead (faking his own death), I'm pretty sure Holmes can manage it.

smile

Top
#662489 - 4th Feb 2012 2:06pm Re: how CAN Sherlock return from the dead? [Re: MattLFC]
yewgarth Offline
Forum Addict

Registered: 2nd Nov 2008
Posts: 1781
Loc: new ferry
The most popular theory is that pathologist Molly Hooper, helped Sherlock in his mission.
Molly, who has had a crush on Sherlock since she met him, could have helped him by faking death and post-mortem certificates and providing a cadaver to bury as well as arranging for the paramedics to be immediately on the scene.
Sherlock is seen asking Molly for help in an earlier scene when he tells her: 'I think I'm going to die'.
Molly, being a coroner/pathologist/wonder lab girl, is the perfect agent for Sherlock's plan. Aware that he will need to fake his own death, he needs to place his faith in someone who can help him die - officially.'
Of course, we mustn't forget that the fall was witnessed by Dr Watson who was speaking to Sherlock on his phone and saw him standing precariously on the rooftop.
But as he runs to reach his friend as he falls, Watson is knocked over by a cyclist which disorientates him, which would be enough of a diversion for Sherlock to pretend to be lying dead on the pavement before being safely taken away in the back of a waiting ambulance.
It has also been suggested that Sherlock's brother Mycroft was in on the plan and arranged for the cyclist to knock Watson down, distracting him from what was going on by the hospital.
Fans have claimed that a rubbish truck is seen pulling up alongside the hospital which Holmes could have landed in before making the body swap.
It is suggested: 'Holmes leaps off the roof, out of view of Watson, lands in the rubbish truck, and violently deposits the body which is hidden inside. It was Mycroft who took care of the details of the plan such as the truck and the bicycle.'
But one viewer suggested that Dr Watson never witnessed a fall because he was hallucinating.
In the second episode, The Hounds of Baskerville, Holmes, Dr Watson and their client Henry Knight, played by Russell Tovey, were drugged which tricked the trio into thinking they had seen a terrifying wild dog - so could it be that Sherlock used the same drug on Watson?

Top
#662644 - 4th Feb 2012 7:28pm Re: how CAN Sherlock return from the dead? [Re: ResearcherTony]
MattLFC Offline
Wiki Master

Registered: 14th Aug 2004
Posts: 22315
Loc: Moreton/Beirut/Mobile
I think I'll just wait until the new series to find out, which apparently might not be until 2013...

It doesn't bother me that much that I'll lose any sleep over it.

smile

Top
#662928 - 5th Feb 2012 10:38am Re: how CAN Sherlock return from the dead? [Re: MattLFC]
StuyMac Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 24th Nov 2003
Posts: 12002
Loc: Wirralshire
Originally Posted By: MattLFC
Well if dirty Den managed to arise from the dead (faking his own death), I'm pretty sure Holmes can manage it.

smile


raftl You have a good point there Matty!
_________________________


What If There Were No Hypothetical Questions?

Top

Moderator:  Mod 
Random Wirral Images

Click to View Topic.
Newest Topics
Fitting bathroom lights need help
by yr20405
Yesterday at 11:29 PM
Charity fishing match
by paul110180
Yesterday at 09:29 PM
Games for children
by granny
Yesterday at 01:35 AM
Are there any doctors or nurses on here.
by granny
16th Nov 2017 11:52pm
Bath Lifts
by locomotive
16th Nov 2017 6:22pm
For Sale & Free
where to get cheap carpet
by mickturner
Yesterday at 04:24 PM
White radiator single panel 1400 x 600 - good cond
by gerrymoore
16th Nov 2017 9:16am
Samsung Galaxy S7 Titanium Silver + Extras
by j_demo
15th Nov 2017 7:29pm
Vaping set
by paul110180
15th Nov 2017 2:37pm
Wanted wii consul box
by dodie
15th Nov 2017 12:19pm
Featured Member
Registered: 16th Aug 2013
Posts: 2120
Newest Members
DarioLo, JohnG74, kerryanne1980, Rooster202, Scruffy
12448 Registered Users
Today's Birthdays
eggandchips (64)
New Wirral Info
Fitting bathroom lights need help
by yr20405
Yesterday at 11:29 PM
Games for children
by granny
Yesterday at 01:35 AM
Bath Lifts
by locomotive
16th Nov 2017 6:22pm
The Lanterns at Chester Zoo
by granny
16th Nov 2017 1:05pm
Travelling Bus and Train Which Tickets?
by fish5133
15th Nov 2017 5:31pm
News : New Topics
Anyone read this ?
by venice
16th Nov 2017 3:22pm
Is this crime against humanity
by granny
13th Nov 2017 4:04pm
Wedding for Cancer Research !
by Katemargaret
11th Nov 2017 10:38pm
The EU and us.
by Excoriator
11th Nov 2017 8:44am
Police, St Josephs Primary, Woodchurch Road
by diggingdeeper
7th Nov 2017 3:55pm
New Enthusiast Forums
Charity fishing match
by paul110180
Yesterday at 09:29 PM
Are there any doctors or nurses on here.
by granny
16th Nov 2017 11:52pm
Taltalk Broadband Dying
by diggingdeeper
15th Nov 2017 3:40am
Replacement Key Fob casing
by fish5133
14th Nov 2017 7:45pm
Insecure sites.
by venice
13th Nov 2017 3:54pm
(Views 24hrs)Trending Newest Topics
Fitting bathroom lights need help 28
Charity fishing match 21
Telephone Caller Alert - they are NOT BT BROADBAND 16
Wirral Sunrise Sunset
Sunrise Sat 7:44am
Sunset Sat 4:10pm
Local Time Sat 8:24am
WikiWirral Can . . . .