WikiWirral is where great friendships are made.
Forum Stats
12247 Members
65 Forums
72880 Topics
982364 Posts
81 posts in the last 24hrs
Max Online: 7831 @ 8th Apr 2013 4:18pm
Who's Online - Click Me
40 registered (alan128, 9 invisible), 1014 Guests and 162 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Social Media : Follow Us


(Views 7days)This Weeks Most Read
What happened to Tranmere car bootie? 578
Martin Mcguinness dies 523
Alloys refurb and colour change. The Wheel Deal. 458
Need advice about Letting 409
Unusual Phone calls 398
File too large 392
Council tax bill for this year 2017 382
British troops to Estonia 342
Has anyone fished 303
1882 Plan of the borough of Birkenhead and Wards 286
New General Forums
Surely the most honest add.....
by buddy
20th Mar 2017 5:43pm
Happy Birthday DIZDAZDOZ
by snowhite
19th Mar 2017 4:24pm
My old friend the fox
by Dilly
18th Mar 2017 11:15am
charity shop bungle..true story
by fish5133
18th Mar 2017 9:11am
New Wirral History
William Bernard's building, Birkenhead
by yoller
20th Mar 2017 4:27pm
1882 Plan of the borough of Birkenhead and Wards
by Dave_Wood
19th Mar 2017 11:57am
New Brighton Coop
by Mike_White
9th Mar 2017 12:48pm
Tranmere High School for Girls 1882 Chesnut Grove
by sarah708
6th Mar 2017 8:23pm
Whetstone Lane, Birkenhead
by MoretonExpat
6th Mar 2017 8:04am
Forum Tips
Photo Gallery Forums
Birkenhead Transport Museum 24th Feb 2017
fireworks on the Mersey last night
Topic Replies
Offset number plates
by Dilly
0 seconds ago
Incident at Westminster
by Gibbo
13 minutes 58 seconds ago
It's Broken : Forum Update
by lollipop
Today at 08:53 AM
Lee and Cragg Quarries - Bacup
by Mark
Today at 07:43 AM
What does this all mean?
by venice
Today at 01:03 AM
Martin Mcguinness dies
by lollipop
Yesterday at 07:20 PM
black contiboard locally?
by venice
Yesterday at 09:59 AM
Port Sunlight
by cools
Yesterday at 09:17 AM
Has anyone fished
by Habdab
Yesterday at 09:04 AM
March
M Tu W Th F Sa Su
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31
Recent Posts : What's On ?
Lee and Cragg Quarries - Bacup
by Mark
07:43 AM
Rufford Old Hall
by diggingdeeper
13th Mar 2017 9:58am
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#578671 - 8th Sep 2011 6:22pm a crime commited?
free_spirit Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 19th Apr 2009
Posts: 452
Loc: wirral
can someone help
with this,

if your are with someone who is commiting a crime, then are you breaking the law too?

its a question my daughter is struggling on for her school work,
she thinks yes, but we not 100% sure..

any help appreciatted, thanks

Top
Law & Order : Advertising
Click me for more Information......

* * * vipimages.co.uk - Photographic services * * *
Now Advertise with WikiWirral.
WikiWirral stats 35,000 Page Views a Day +500 Search Engines.. Click Me
#578674 - 8th Sep 2011 6:33pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: free_spirit]
lau2908 Offline
Forum Addict

Registered: 5th Jun 2010
Posts: 1400
Loc: wallasey
i would have said yes but i am not 100% either

Top
#578675 - 8th Sep 2011 6:33pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: free_spirit]
pokerchamp Offline
Wise One

Registered: 29th Aug 2011
Posts: 820
Loc: wallasey
do you mean with them at the scene of the crime or in a relationship with them knowing they are commiting a crime?

Top
#578683 - 8th Sep 2011 6:42pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: pokerchamp]
free_spirit Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 19th Apr 2009
Posts: 452
Loc: wirral
Originally Posted By: pokerchamp
do you mean with them at the scene of the crime or in a relationship with them knowing they are commiting a crime?


actually there at the scene of where the crime is being commited..

Top
#578685 - 8th Sep 2011 6:42pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: pokerchamp]
yewgarth Offline
Forum Addict

Registered: 2nd Nov 2008
Posts: 1781
Loc: new ferry
wouldn't that be aiding and abetting?

Top
#578688 - 8th Sep 2011 6:44pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: yewgarth]
free_spirit Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 19th Apr 2009
Posts: 452
Loc: wirral
Originally Posted By: yewgarth
wouldn't that be aiding and abetting?


not sure,
its just asks would you be breaking the law if your with somebody while they are commiting a crime

Top
#578691 - 8th Sep 2011 6:50pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: free_spirit]
pokerchamp Offline
Wise One

Registered: 29th Aug 2011
Posts: 820
Loc: wallasey
depends on the nature of the crime!!if your with someone and they punch someone in the face then they will be charged with GBH and there would be no charge because you didnt do anything but if you were with someone and they were comitting stealing a car then yes you prob would be charged with that!!!its a hard one but i would definatley say it depends on the nature of the crime!!hope this helps.

Top
#578694 - 8th Sep 2011 6:54pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: free_spirit]
TheDr Offline
Forum Master

Registered: 23rd Feb 2010
Posts: 2631
Loc: Wirral
It depends on the crime, and how in-depth you go depends what level their "school work" is at.

To commit a crime you must (normally) have to have Mens Rea (guilty/evil mind) in that you KNOW that are committing a crime, or at least, what you are doing is wrong (so obviously a 2 year old grabbing sweets in a shop isn't theft as they don't know the difference, but for someone older it could well be).

Some offences don't even need you to be WITH the person, for example, someone gets stopped driving a friends car, and they are dsqualified from driving, the person driving is guilty of the crime (driving whilst disqualified, no insurance), however their passengers are guilty of no offence, HOWEVER the OWNER of the vehicle, (even if not present), if they knew that their friend was using the car could still be guilty of allowing them to use it knowing they were disqualified, and it would be up to them to prove that either they didn't know, or that they took "reasonable" steps to check (the driver showed them a licence etc).

The part I think they are getting at is if two (or more) people set out to commit a crime, such as burglary. If two people break into a house, that is the crime, if whilst it is being done one of the burglars then assaults, or kills, someone on the premises, then both would be guilty of the higher offence (aggravated burglary or murder). If one of the people was waiting in the car outside at the time, he would STILL be guilty of the offence. His only defence would be that he didn't know that the other person was committing a burglary (his friend had asked him to give him a lift to someones house to collect something he had bought etc), obviously this would hold much more weight if it was a 4 in the afternoon rather than 4 in the morning.

If two people are walking along the road and one just decides to smash a window then if the other had no idea they were going to do this and it was completely unforseeable, no he has committed no offence, if he had any idea this was going to happen or he (for example) dared the other one to do it, then yes he is guilty.

If this all sounds complicated, it is, if it means that the answer is "sometimes", then it is, if this is why people with fancy solicitors get off with things they have done by quoting obscure cases, it is.

If you need any more help just pm me.

Top
#578728 - 8th Sep 2011 7:54pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: TheDr]
free_spirit Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 19th Apr 2009
Posts: 452
Loc: wirral
Originally Posted By: TheDr
It depends on the crime, and how in-depth you go depends what level their "school work" is at.

To commit a crime you must (normally) have to have Mens Rea (guilty/evil mind) in that you KNOW that are committing a crime, or at least, what you are doing is wrong (so obviously a 2 year old grabbing sweets in a shop isn't theft as they don't know the difference, but for someone older it could well be).

Some offences don't even need you to be WITH the person, for example, someone gets stopped driving a friends car, and they are dsqualified from driving, the person driving is guilty of the crime (driving whilst disqualified, no insurance), however their passengers are guilty of no offence, HOWEVER the OWNER of the vehicle, (even if not present), if they knew that their friend was using the car could still be guilty of allowing them to use it knowing they were disqualified, and it would be up to them to prove that either they didn't know, or that they took "reasonable" steps to check (the driver showed them a licence etc).

The part I think they are getting at is if two (or more) people set out to commit a crime, such as burglary. If two people break into a house, that is the crime, if whilst it is being done one of the burglars then assaults, or kills, someone on the premises, then both would be guilty of the higher offence (aggravated burglary or murder). If one of the people was waiting in the car outside at the time, he would STILL be guilty of the offence. His only defence would be that he didn't know that the other person was committing a burglary (his friend had asked him to give him a lift to someones house to collect something he had bought etc), obviously this would hold much more weight if it was a 4 in the afternoon rather than 4 in the morning.

If two people are walking along the road and one just decides to smash a window then if the other had no idea they were going to do this and it was completely unforseeable, no he has committed no offence, if he had any idea this was going to happen or he (for example) dared the other one to do it, then yes he is guilty.

If this all sounds complicated, it is, if it means that the answer is "sometimes", then it is, if this is why people with fancy solicitors get off with things they have done by quoting obscure cases, it is.

If you need any more help just pm me.


that was great, helped her loads, thanks very much for the examples.
appreciatted you taking the time.

Top
#578732 - 8th Sep 2011 8:00pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: free_spirit]
Moonstar Offline

Forum Addict

Registered: 2nd Jul 2011
Posts: 1240
Loc: Wirral
Isn't the Doc one smart bloke.

Top
#578740 - 8th Sep 2011 8:08pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: free_spirit]
TheDr Offline
Forum Master

Registered: 23rd Feb 2010
Posts: 2631
Loc: Wirral
Originally Posted By: free_spirit
that was great, helped her loads, thanks very much for the examples.
appreciatted you taking the time.


No worries, hope it all makes sense for her, if she gets stuck just send me a pm and I'll try and help.

No I won't do everyones homework laugh

Top
#578760 - 8th Sep 2011 8:37pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: free_spirit]
debbiejames1985 Offline
Newbeee

Registered: 17th Feb 2009
Posts: 14
Loc: Wirral
is TheDr a real doctor?

Top
#578762 - 8th Sep 2011 8:42pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: TheDr]
free_spirit Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 19th Apr 2009
Posts: 452
Loc: wirral
Originally Posted By: TheDr
Originally Posted By: free_spirit
that was great, helped her loads, thanks very much for the examples.
appreciatted you taking the time.


No worries, hope it all makes sense for her, if she gets stuck just send me a pm and I'll try and help.

No I won't do everyones homework laugh


thanks happy

Top
#578838 - 8th Sep 2011 10:40pm Re: a crime commited? [Re: Moonstar]
yewgarth Offline
Forum Addict

Registered: 2nd Nov 2008
Posts: 1781
Loc: new ferry
Originally Posted By: Moonstar
Isn't the Doc one smart bloke.


yes he gets it from me hi

Top
#579108 - 9th Sep 2011 9:39am Re: a crime commited? [Re: free_spirit]
Boogles Offline
Newbeee

Registered: 6th Jul 2011
Posts: 31
Loc: Heswall
Quite simply put, aiding and abetting is assisting in the crime. So again quite simply put, being present is not committing a crime, you can probably answer that question with one word.

Kind regards,
Ian

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >

Moderator:  Mod 
Random Wirral Images

Click to View Topic.
Newest Topics
Offset number plates
by venice
01:24 AM
What does this all mean?
by venice
12:20 PM
black contiboard locally?
by fish5133
21st Mar 2017 9:30pm
Port Sunlight
by alan128
21st Mar 2017 10:09am
Council tax bill for this year 2017
by keef666
20th Mar 2017 10:25pm
For Sale & Free
Nail Varnish Stands X 2 (holds 50 in each one)
by j_demo
20th Mar 2017 5:49pm
Ipad
by madrob
19th Mar 2017 5:15pm
windows 7 64bit pc
by brady
18th Mar 2017 4:49pm
Petrol Lawnmower to purchase
by saltytom
18th Mar 2017 8:42am
2004 saab turbo 93 aero
by vw_kyle
16th Mar 2017 3:18pm
Featured Member
Registered: 27th Nov 2011
Posts: 47
Newest Members
Monkeyboyliam121, andreap, LairdLad, HollandGj, petaann
12247 Registered Users
Today's Birthdays
No Birthdays
New Wirral Info
What does this all mean?
by venice
12:20 PM
black contiboard locally?
by fish5133
21st Mar 2017 9:30pm
Port Sunlight
by alan128
21st Mar 2017 10:09am
Council tax bill for this year 2017
by keef666
20th Mar 2017 10:25pm
What happened to Tranmere car bootie?
by MikeT
18th Mar 2017 6:27am
News : New Topics
Incident at Westminster
by granny
03:40 PM
Martin Mcguinness dies
by Dilly
21st Mar 2017 9:29am
British troops to Estonia
by fish5133
18th Mar 2017 8:16am
Unusual Phone calls
by granny
16th Mar 2017 3:53pm
Thanks
by Christinerowland
14th Mar 2017 8:11pm
New Enthusiast Forums
Offset number plates
by venice
01:24 AM
File too large
by Dilly
20th Mar 2017 10:41am
ford focus 1.6 t reg rattling
by Little_B
19th Mar 2017 11:02pm
Alloys refurb and colour change. The Wheel Deal.
by TheComputerLab
18th Mar 2017 9:17am
Has anyone fished
by Habdab
17th Mar 2017 8:43pm
(Views 24hrs)Trending Newest Topics
Incident at Westminster 228
What does this all mean? 142
Offset number plates 90
Wirral Sunrise Sunset
Sunrise Thu 6:05am
Sunset Thu 6:31pm
Local Time Thu 10:34am
WikiWirral Can . . . .