Forums
Posted By: Wheels Best computer for video editing? - 27th Oct 2011 9:52pm
I've not used mac before, are they good for this? Or are the intel i3 processors with a decent graphics card any good?. Any help would be nice even links to some goodies smile
Posted By: diggingdeeper Re: Best computer for video editing? - 27th Oct 2011 9:56pm
Graphics card doesn't make that much difference, plenty of hdd, memory and processor speed.

Got to be a well cooled processor, video editing can run the processor flat out for extended periods.
Posted By: ex0__ Re: Best computer for video editing? - 27th Oct 2011 10:18pm
There's nothing you could do with a mac that you can't do with a cheaper windows machine.

What exactly is it you're editing? If you're talking about 5min youtube videos any standard machine will be fine. Pick up a box from ebuyer for like £250 and that'd do the job. If you're talking about serious HD editing it'd be worth aiming for 6-8gb RAM and a decent aftermarket air heatsink for whatever CPU you end up with (i5 or i7 ideally).
Posted By: TheComputerLab Re: Best computer for video editing? - 27th Oct 2011 10:33pm
IMO:

People prefer using a mac for editing not only because a top of the range mac is much more powerful than say a top end Dell BUT because the Mac has a better OS for things like video and music related things.

the top end mac costs... wait for it... £16000!

You can however if you want a MAC but cant afford one build a Hack! hackintosh is a MAC OSX operating system running on a normal PC. exactly the same in every way, you can even get a mouse and keyboard.

a budget of about £1000 will see you with the perfect PC for video editing, Ram is quite cheap at the moment so i would even consider putting 12gb in, nice 120gb solid state drive and an i7.

If your budget is sub 500 quid though... i5 and 8gb of ram should get you started.

I love buying top notch computers!!

just spotted this, have a watch of the vid.

http://www.hackintosh.com/#hackintosh_compatible
Posted By: Laraine Re: Best computer for video editing? - 27th Oct 2011 10:48pm
Apple do a mac mini, we have one for graphics work and its far superior to a PC, and far more stable, you just need to get a monitor and an apple keyboard as when you buy it, you just get the mac. You can sometimes get them on ebay,
Laraine
Posted By: Laraine Re: Best computer for video editing? - 27th Oct 2011 11:02pm
Originally Posted by Laraine
Apple do a mac mini, we have one for graphics work and its far superior to a PC, and far more stable, you just need to get a monitor and an apple keyboard as when you buy it, you just get the mac. You can sometimes get them on ebay,
Laraine


opps forgot the link
http://www.apple.com/ilife/imovie/
Posted By: ex0__ Re: Best computer for video editing? - 27th Oct 2011 11:04pm
When it comes to macs this link will help:

http://i.imgur.com/H4CK4.jpg
Posted By: GrandMasterFlash Re: Best computer for video editing? - 27th Oct 2011 11:12pm
Don't forget themacuser.org

I'm kidding, don't go there tease
Posted By: ex0__ Re: Best computer for video editing? - 28th Oct 2011 8:11am
Lul, can't shocksite me XD
Posted By: Wheels Re: Best computer for video editing? - 28th Oct 2011 10:06am
Originally Posted by ex0__
There's nothing you could do with a mac that you can't do with a cheaper windows machine.

What exactly is it you're editing? If you're talking about 5min youtube videos any standard machine will be fine. Pick up a box from ebuyer for like £250 and that'd do the job. If you're talking about serious HD editing it'd be worth aiming for 6-8gb RAM and a decent aftermarket air heatsink for whatever CPU you end up with (i5 or i7 ideally).


yer I use HD MP4 and AVCHD Format up to 120FPS, My current Desktop is a self build quadcore 3gbRam 1gb ATI on win7 (about 3-4 years old I think). I dont know If I should just upgrade my current PC... I have the funds to buy a good spec one but as you posted that link before I know building my own is better/cheaper I just havent got a clue whats good anymore or where to buy from. Im gonna have a look on that ebuyer now.
Posted By: little_pob Re: Best computer for video editing? - 28th Oct 2011 10:21am
Are Macs any good at video editing? Any of the current range will be allow you to do some type of video editing. (As long as you aren't talking about the AppleTV ;))

You will more than likely get better spec for the money by going for a Windows or Linux based machine. However, if you post your budget, form factor (i.e. desktop or laptop) and the Mac you are looking at we can say for certain one way or the other.
Originally Posted by TheComputerLab
...
the top end mac costs... wait for it... £16000!
The most expensive system listed on the Mac webstore is the Mac Pro "12 core" (2x 6 core Intel Xeon processors) for £4083. Whilst you will need a monitor with that, even the 27" Apple Cinema Display is 'only' £899.
Posted By: little_pob Re: Best computer for video editing? - 28th Oct 2011 10:27am
Originally Posted by Wheels
Originally Posted by ex0__
There's nothing you could do with a mac that you can't do with a cheaper windows machine.

What exactly is it you're editing? If you're talking about 5min youtube videos any standard machine will be fine. Pick up a box from ebuyer for like £250 and that'd do the job. If you're talking about serious HD editing it'd be worth aiming for 6-8gb RAM and a decent aftermarket air heatsink for whatever CPU you end up with (i5 or i7 ideally).


yer I use HD MP4 and AVCHD Format up to 120FPS, My current Desktop is a self build quadcore 3gbRam 1gb ATI on win7 (about 3-4 years old I think). I dont know If I should just upgrade my current PC... I have the funds to buy a good spec one but as you posted that link before I know building my own is better/cheaper I just havent got a clue whats good anymore or where to buy from. Im gonna have a look on that ebuyer now.

Depending on budget: Intel i5 2500K or i7 2600K in a H67 or Z68 chipset motherbaord. 8GB+ of DDR3 1600MHz. 120/128GB SATA3 SSD for a boot drive. 1-2TB HDD for storage drives. BluRay burner...

Either recycle your graphics card or add in nothing lower than the GeForce 550Ti or Radeon HD 5770.
Posted By: ex0__ Re: Best computer for video editing? - 28th Oct 2011 10:44am
Could prob get away with a 64gb boot drive (OCZ Vertex 2 or something) and make sure you get a decent case (HAF - X is awesome if you don't mind shelling out for it) with a decent top fan and a few quiet 120mm's. A good PSU (coolermaster gold or corsair tx 750w) would help as well.

Also you'll want a decent aftermarket cooler to go with i5/i7, worth picking up a H50 from amazon to cool it. Doesn't really count as watercooling since it's just a block and a pump/rad combined but they perform quite well.
Posted By: Anonymous Re: Best computer for video editing? - 29th Oct 2011 8:39am
Originally Posted by ex0__
There's nothing you could do with a mac that you can't do with a cheaper windows machine.

What exactly is it you're editing? If you're talking about 5min youtube videos any standard machine will be fine. Pick up a box from ebuyer for like £250 and that'd do the job. If you're talking about serious HD editing it'd be worth aiming for 6-8gb RAM and a decent aftermarket air heatsink for whatever CPU you end up with (i5 or i7 ideally).


Must be a cheepskate windoze user with no idea of what you want whatsover.... Do not listen to this bullshit...If you seriously want to play video a Mac it HAS to be !!!

For him I guess a Mac is an item of clothing for when it is pissing down outside!
Posted By: ex0__ Re: Best computer for video editing? - 29th Oct 2011 3:41pm
Check out that picture I linked above Andy. The mac section? That's all about you. Keep hugging that £2k apple while I edit the same videos on my £300 nix box that runs faster than your mac did when you first got it.

There's 3 types of people that get macs:

1) professional djs/music/photo engineers that are power users (about 0.01% of mac users fall into this category)
2) people that like shiny apple hardware and have more money than sense (about 9.99% of users)
3) people that take advice from people like you because they don't know better (the other 90% of users)
© Wirral-Wikiwirral