WikiWirral Wirral's Biggest Online Forum
Forum Statistics
Forums65
Topics76,352
Posts1,033,280
Members14,560
Most Online16,551
Feb 2nd, 2024
Who's Online Now
11 members (ArranGirl13, 3 invisible), 7,969 guests, and 428 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Top Posters
sunnyside 45,164
MattLFC 22,315
Mark 21,269
granny 17,788
_Ste_ 16,345
Newest Members
Kalena1962, rattus, Lisrush, Emotecreative, ArranGirl13
14,560 Registered Users
New General Forums
New Wirral History
Tall Brick Chimneys
by diggingdeeper - 16th Mar 2024 11:56am
D.I.Y. / Building Shop
by mharford91 - 3rd Mar 2024 8:53pm
1970's Murder in Central Park, Wallasey
by cutespam - 4th Aug 2018 10:28am
Old Hall in Higher Bebington
by Rhoobarb - 25th May 2010 5:55pm
Oleo Works
by Ducko - 14th May 2008 3:09pm
Top Posters(30 Days)
granny 14
casper 13
bri445 4
Topic Replies
Facial recognition coming in supermarkets?
by diggingdeeper - 27th Mar 2024 3:50pm
Bolts at Bebington Road
by diggingdeeper - 27th Mar 2024 2:33am
Hot Spot Chippie Broadway
by Excoriator - 26th Mar 2024 7:57pm
Tall Brick Chimneys
by diggingdeeper - 26th Mar 2024 5:43pm
Lost river (Well, brook really)
by diggingdeeper - 26th Mar 2024 3:09am
Old Hall in Higher Bebington
by diggingdeeper - 24th Mar 2024 5:58pm
Netflix 3 Body Problem.
by BultacoAstro - 22nd Mar 2024 8:04am
Wisper electric bike. 36v .
by Dilly - 21st Mar 2024 7:36pm
This is Elvis
by GingerTom - 21st Mar 2024 9:27am
March
M T W T F S S
1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Top Likes Received (30 Days)
Kylix 1
cools 1
Top Likes Received
bert1 14
Mark 4
granny 3
casper 3
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
#330410 16th Jun 2009 6:17pm
_
_jase_
Unregistered
_jase_
Unregistered
_
Can children be criminals?

[Linked Image]

What is the right age to hold children responsible for their criminal acts? Eight? 10? 14? 18?

With a spate of violent crime being committed by seemingly ever younger people, the question has never been more difficult to answer, or more important.
Plans to raise the age of criminal responsibility in Scotland from eight to 12 will leave England, Wales and Northern Ireland with the lowest such age in Europe, at just 10.

In Spain it is 16, in Belgium 18. So, should the rest of the UK follow Scotland? Or perhaps raise the age even higher?

At Thames Youth Court in east London, 15 year-old-Germaine (not his real name) pleaded guilty to a robbing a pizza delivery driver. But should he have been in court?

"I think it's a good thing because they will learn that this is what leads you into jail," his mother said.

The Bulger murder

Much of the debate that rages around the age of criminal responsibility is rooted in the 1993 prosecution of Jon Venables and Robert Thompson for the brutal murder of two-year-old James Bulger in Liverpool.
[Linked Image]
Back then, in addition to the overwhelming national revulsion at the abduction and murder, there was also a heated debate as to whether two boys, aged 10 at the time of the killing, should stand trial for murder.

The case and the haunting, grainy CCTV images of the two boys leading the toddler from a shopping centre to his death still resonate powerfully today.

In recent years, however, new scientific evidence has shed further light on the way children's brains develop.

Knowing right from wrong


"There's a very substantial evidence base to show that children aged 10 are not fully mature," said Dr Eileen Vizard, a child psychiatrist with the NSPCC's Child Offender Service.

"They show developmental immaturity in terms of their physical, intellectual, emotional, and social development," she said.

She points to recent evidence on the structure and functioning of young brains which suggests that development continues beyond adolescence and into the mid-20s.

Though children of 10 may know the difference between "big rights and big wrongs", Dr Vizard believes they do not have the capacity to participate fully and fairly in a criminal trial, and that 14 or 15 should be a bare minimum age for criminal responsibility.

Perhaps surprisingly though, Laurence Lee, the solicitor who represented Jon Venables, takes issue with that:

"It's impossible to say that you can't prosecute children of 10 because their brains aren't sufficiently developed. For society's own protection there should be the potential and the possibility of a 10-year-old being prosecuted.

"I think the crime rate would rocket if that sword of Damocles didn't exist over a young defendant's head."

Last year more than 11,000 young people between the ages of 10 and 13 were prosecuted in the criminal courts in England and Wales. In the 14 to 17-year-old category that rose to around 107,000.

In court

At Thames Youth Court, a small 13-year-old boy appeared on a charge of racially aggravated assault.

When aged 12, he had allegedly hit a girl he knew and called her a "Paki". The two lived on the same estate and the claimed injuries were relatively minor.

At a preliminary hearing in court the judge asked the Crown Prosecution Service whether it was really in the public interest that the case proceeded. It showed no inclination to discontinue it.

When he was asked which parts of the proceedings were difficult to follow, the boy replied, "All of it".

His mother said she thought it ridiculous that a full trial take place. She believes children should be dealt with outside court.

"Their parents should be spoken to, they should be warned," she said.

She was angry that following a one or two-day trial in a few months time, her son could be found guilty and would get a criminal record.

Other young people in court that day were there for a variety of assaults, thefts and robberies.

Those who pleaded guilty, or were found guilty, would also get a criminal record.

Norwegian law

In Norway, the age of criminal responsibility is 15 and there is a far more welfare-based approach to the problem of child offending.

Reidar Hjermann, the Norwegian Children's Ombudsman, believes 10 is far too young.

"A child does not choose to commit or not commit a crime," he said. "They do it because they have a difficult life."

Lynne Costello from Mothers Against Murder and Aggression (MAMAA), which supports families whose children have been murdered and provides education programmes for the young, disagrees.

"The kids know the law is soft," she said. "If we raise the age they will be getting younger people to carry their weapons or their drugs.

"We have to tell children 'you have done wrong', and if that means going through the court system that's what we have to do."

Setting the age of criminal responsibility is fantastically difficult. People do not want to demonise children, but worry about a younger generation with greater temptations and looser boundaries.

The government has no plans to raise the current age of 10, but many lawyers and child psychiatrists believe there is a strong case for doing so.

Law In Action will be broadcast on BBC Radio 4 on Tuesday 16 June at 1600 GMT. You can listen to the programme for seven days afterwards via the BBC iPlayer , or download the free podcast .

THE BBC


Google Ads
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 22,315
Wiki Master
Offline
Wiki Master
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 22,315
Once they hit 13, they are imho, well aware of their actions. I know for sure I knew the difference between right and wrong, it's common sense more than anything.

Teenager = young adult nowadays. They all want to act and behave like young adults, want to be treated like youg adults, and thus should take responsibility like young adults.

Joined: May 2008
Posts: 4,119
Forum Guardian
Offline
Forum Guardian
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 4,119
Either the child or the parents are responsible for the actions of the child.
If the law considers that the child is too young to be in the dock then the parents should appear.
We cannot say that the child is too young therefore no one is responsible - IMHO.
If the parent has to answer for their child's actions they may be inclined to take an interest in their whereabouts.
Maybe I'm over simplifying it but it makes sense to me.

Last edited by Softy_Southerner; 16th Jun 2009 6:38pm.
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 86
Member
Offline
Member
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 86
Originally Posted by Softy_Southerner
Either the child or the parents are responsible for the actions of the child.
If the law considers that the child is too young to be in the dock then the parents should appear.
We cannot say that the child is too young therefore no one is responsible - IMHO.
If the parent has to answer for their child's actions they may be inclined to take an interest in their whereabouts.
Maybe I'm over simplifying it but it makes sense to me.


I totally agree. It was drilled into us as kids that the minute we stepped out of the front door we were representative of the good family we came from. It was made clear that Anything we did to shame the family would be punished. Irrespective of the law, incidentally !

Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 578
Smartchild
Offline
Smartchild
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 578
I think children can play the system, the adults and the social workers. In Scotland children under 16 are dealt with via childrens' hearings and not in open court, unless it is in the public's interest.

If they choose to accept the child is responsible at 12 then they have neglected the precident:- Mary Bell was 11 when she was given a life sentence in 1968 after being found guilty of the manslaughter of four-year-old Martin Brown, and Brian Howe, 3, on the grounds of diminished responsibility.


As mentioned, age was discussed in Scotland and that there should be an absolute bar against prosecuting children under the age of 12. Although opinion on consultation was divided, the majority of those responding favoured a bar. A bar at this age would be consistent with the requirements of the European Convention of Human Rights. 12 is also the age at which a child is presumed to have sufficient maturity and understanding for many civil law purposes, including participating in civil court proceedings.

A children's hearing should be able to deal with all children who commit offences even if they are too young to be prosecuted. At present a child under 8 is presumed not to be guilty of any offence and it has been held (Merrin v S 1987 SLT 193) that such a child cannot be referred to a hearing on the ground of having committed an offence.

I do not think Scotland will differ from England - we can always adhere to the requirements of the European Convention of Human Rights, stating 12 as the age of responsibility. This legislation will ultimately win in our law courts. Although it would be appropriate for us to set our own age as we see fit.

Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 14,343
Likes: 19
Wiki Master
Offline
Wiki Master
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 14,343
Likes: 19
Ignoring the few hardcore kids, there are many that need some sort threat in place to discourage them from doing wrong. Kids like many adults think that a victimless crime os ok, but the child is not capable of foreseeing what is victimless - how many times do you here statements like "its ok it will be insured" or "it didn't really hurt him".

Parents have no longer the power to be responsible for their kids, they aren't allowed to smack, they are not allowed to lock children in rooms etc etc and the kids know it! If a child walks out the house and commits a crime, how is it fair that the parent is responsible.

Kids should be responsible for their actions, it should be up to some judicial system to decide punishment on individual basis. Record should be wiped when they leave school but reinstated on first crime.

If kids aren't resposible it won't be long before you have older kids running their own private armies of crime-exempt soldiers ... then what?


We don't do charity in Germany, we pay taxes. Charity is a failure of governments' responsibilities - Henning Wehn

https://ddue.uk
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 1,641
Forum Addict
Offline
Forum Addict
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 1,641
The do- gooders of this world are blinkered to the problems that they have created. In the 40s and 50s if you did wrong at school you got the cane, if do did wrong in the street a neighbour dragged to to your parents and you got belted. there where still a few bad lads but in general most kids respected there elders. Respect and knowing if you did wrong and got caught you where punished kept you in line.


Ships that pass in the night, seldom seen and soon forgoten
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 14,343
Likes: 19
Wiki Master
Offline
Wiki Master
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 14,343
Likes: 19
If you got the cane at school, you got belted when you got home!

Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 3,557
Forum Guardian
Offline
Forum Guardian
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 3,557
i can remember getting a clip round the ear of the local beat bobby for smoking mid 60s and then he took me home told me mum ouch that's for bringing a policeman to the door.respect and manners cost nothing...


Does your vacuum suck? Get a Dyson!!


Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 22,315
Wiki Master
Offline
Wiki Master
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 22,315
Originally Posted by diggingdeeper
If you got the cane at school, you got belted when you got home!

Yeah, my uncle confessed to recieving the cane to my grandad... on his deathbead. Seriously, he was in his final couple of days having lost the fight to cancer, and he confessed that to my grandad.

He said he had been petrified of revealing it when he was younger, cos he'd get a clip round the ear (funnily enough, my grandad was the local bobby) and would have felt ashamed...

How times and social attitudes change eh!


Moderated by  Mod 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Random Wirral Images

Click to View Topic.
Newest Topics
Facial recognition coming in supermarkets?
by Excoriator - 27th Mar 2024 10:52am
Hot Spot Chippie Broadway
by Excoriator - 26th Mar 2024 7:57pm
Bolts at Bebington Road
by Excoriator - 23rd Mar 2024 9:48am
Netflix 3 Body Problem.
by BultacoAstro - 22nd Mar 2024 8:04am
Tall Brick Chimneys
by diggingdeeper - 16th Mar 2024 11:56am
For Sale & Free
Wisper electric bike. 36v .
by Dilly - 21st Mar 2024 7:36pm
This is Elvis
by GingerTom - 17th Mar 2024 2:37pm
Member Spotlight
diggingdeeper
diggingdeeper
Wirral
Posts: 14,343
Joined: July 2008
Today's Birthdays
There are no members with birthdays on this day.
New Wirral Info
Facial recognition coming in supermarkets?
by Excoriator - 27th Mar 2024 10:52am
Hot Spot Chippie Broadway
by Excoriator - 26th Mar 2024 7:57pm
Bolts at Bebington Road
by Excoriator - 23rd Mar 2024 9:48am
Get your Money Tree ready
by keef666 - 22nd Mar 2023 12:27pm
Restaurant/pub with outdoor seating - Bromborough
by CarterUSM - 7th Aug 2020 7:59pm
News : New Topics
Gaza
by diggingdeeper - 29th Oct 2023 9:28am
Lost river (Well, brook really)
by Excoriator - 10th Sep 2019 8:50am
New Enthusiast Forums
Netflix 3 Body Problem.
by BultacoAstro - 22nd Mar 2024 8:04am
Xbox
by TudorBlue - 3rd Mar 2024 8:48pm
Wiper mechanism needed
by Peter0787 - 20th Feb 2024 4:07pm
Popular Topics(Views)
5,069,750 WIKI WALK CHAT
4,013,797 Spotted!
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5