WikiWirral values you and your opinion.
Forum Stats
12131 Members
65 Forums
72375 Topics
975990 Posts
67 posts in the last 24hrs
Max Online: 7831 @ 8th Apr 2013 4:18pm
Who's Online - Click Me
79 registered (11kendo, 11 invisible), 1552 Guests and 208 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Social Media : Follow Us


(Views 7days)This Weeks Most Read
Disgusting surely not legal creamfields noise !!@ 1217
anything with castors 785
Pensby Hotel 457
Wirral Globe 420
loud music in new brighton 408
Sports Personality Of The Year 362
Cubitts Holland and Hannen 309
Raspberry Pi in the classroom! 291
PC Repair needed 263
HMT Lancastria 178
New General Forums
Lib/dems rule the day
by JimmyG
10:59 PM
Daft funny joke
by venice
05:54 PM
We dont learn much.
by venice
1st Dec 2016 9:22pm
Freegle
by venice
1st Dec 2016 6:36pm
New Wirral History
Name help
by Paternoster21
08:03 AM
HMT Lancastria
by granny
11:38 PM
Cubitts Holland and Hannen
by fish5133
27th Nov 2016 5:38pm
Fire station
by chris7777
22nd Nov 2016 12:24pm
Buy a house in Greasby for 12s a week - in 1935
by yoller
6th Oct 2016 6:56pm
Forum Tips
Photo Gallery Forums
fireworks on the Mersey last night
Hadlow train station
Topic Replies
live webcam from africa, a must see
by venice
HMT Lancastria
by granny
02:06 PM
Stanlow Abbey
by Kylix
02:05 PM
Name help
by fish5133
01:21 PM
Sports Personality Of The Year
by fish5133
01:16 PM
Raspberry Pi in the classroom!
by diggingdeeper
12:45 AM
Wirral Globe
by Excoriator
11:02 PM
What are you currently reading?
by RUDEBOX
10:30 PM
Paying for EU Citizenship (Poll)
by diggingdeeper
10:19 PM
December
M Tu W Th F Sa Su
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31
Recent Posts : What's On ?
Wirral TUC Meeting re Update on Wallasey CLP Suspe
by RUDEBOX
30th Nov 2016 9:16pm
World Aids Day Event 2016. Liverpool
by RUDEBOX
30th Nov 2016 9:05pm
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#266515 - 28th Oct 2008 12:57pm The mpg mythbusters
BMW Joe Offline
Wiki Master

Registered: 30th Apr 2006
Posts: 12369
Loc: Birkenhead
There are many theories on how to improve economy, but which ones actually work?




Autoexpress did some tests with a Vauxhall Astra 1.9 CDTI SRi


Air-conditioning

The first test simply involved pushing a button on the centre console to activate the air-con. There was a slight change in engine revs as Alan did it, then he and Anthony headed out on to the route.

Sixteen minutes later, they were back – with some dramatic results. “It’s made an eight per cent difference,” explained Anthony. “The mpg has gone from the baseline of 30.5mpg to 28mpg.” His computer highlighted the biggest difference was on the city course. “If I isolate that 0.8-mile stage from the whole route, Alan was getting only 20.2mpg: it was 25.6mpg on the baseline run.” He explained that because the engine revs were lower, the vehicle is running slower, so there’s an effect on economy. “What’s also interesting is that when we were on the bowl, the difference in fuel use between the baseline run and with air-con on is virtually nothing. They were both around 39mpg.”


Open windows

Here’s another piece of accepted wisdom for getting the most out of a tank of fuel; if you have the air-con off, you should open the windows for fresh air. But only open them very slightly or it spoils your aerodynamics and cuts economy. After a couple of laps of Millbrook, we can safely say that’s rubbish! On the first run we had the front two open a third, and fuel economy was only a tenth off the baseline measurement. Going out again, with the two windows fully open, it knocked the figure down by a further two-tenths.


Tyre pressures

A tyre with low pressure has a larger footprint on the road, which means a greater rolling resistance. In short, it means the engine has to work harder and more fuel is used. The Astra’s tyres were checked at the start of the day and were at Vauxhall’s recommended figures of 39psi at the front and 36psi at the rear. For this lap of our circuit, we took all four down to 20psi to see what impact it had.

The result surprised everyone. Anthony’s box of tricks showed fuel economy only dipped a fraction at 29.7mpg. In fact, we ran the test a second time to ensure the figures were right, and got a similar outcome. “I would have thought there would be a big difference between the test and our baseline,” Anthony explained. “But the two graphs are virtually the same.”

Alan had reported very little in the way of handling difference on the two runs, and the only conclusion we could draw was that it was down to the Astra’s low-profile tyres. “Things would be very different in the wet,” warned our expert.



Three in the rear

It was time to get cosy on the Astra’s back seat. Across the whole course, the Vauxhall’s average dipped from 30.5mpg to 27.2mpg. But delving into the results revealed more information. “The additional weight makes hardly any difference on the low speeds of the city course,” Anthony said. “But at any other point where the car is accelerating – especially going uphill – it’s clear on the graphs where the figures drop.” Isolating the 1.7-mile hill route from the total, Alan was getting 28.4mpg on the baseline run, but that fell to 25.5mpg when the car was loaded with passengers.


Roofbars and box

Getting rid of add-ons when they’re not needed is standard advice if you’re looking to boost your mpg. Why? Because every car is designed to have a low drag, and a roofbox will spoil that. Wrong! Our test with a Thule product showed that even when filled with 72kg of ballast, close to the maximum load limit of 75kg, it only took 0.2mpg off the baseline.

“I’m quite surprised, I thought it would be more,” said Anthony. “I guess it’s because roofbox makers attempt to make them as aerodynamic as possible.” To prove the point, driver Alan said there was no additional wind noise from the box as he was lapping the track.


Holiday time!

We left the loaded roofbox on the Astra and added a Thule bike rack with two adult cycles. We also put our three volunteers in the back of the car and fired up the air-con again. This was our worst-case scenario, simulating a family with a laden car heading off on a camping holiday.

It won’t be a shock to learn we got the lowest result, at 24.1mpg. But Anthony revealed there was very little difference to the baseline figure when simulating motorway driving on the bowl. “You can see the impact most on the hill route, with the baseline of 28.4mpg on that section down to 24.2mpg,” he explained.


Higher speeds

This was our final test. From our experience on the MPG Marathon in the MINI JCW, we knew that slowing down can have a massive impact on fuel economy. But exactly how much? We set the Vauxhall Astra up on Millbrook’s high-speed bowl to do a single lap at 60, 70, 80 and 90mph. Our first run gave a very creditable 52.4mpg, but as our speed built, it soon tailed off.

At 70mph the average was down to 42.3mpg, at 80mph it was 39.7mpg, while 90mph saw it down to 36.1mpg. That’s 16mpg less than travelling at 60mph. Anthony wasn’t surprised. “At 60mph the Astra pulled 1,700rpm, but at 90mph it was 2,600rpm. By keeping the revs low you’re not working the engine so hard and don’t use as much fuel,” he explained.

Powertrain manager Neil Fulton was fascinated by our findings. “These results are a snapshot of one car on one day, but it’s clear that passenger and cargo weight makes a big difference to vehicle economy.”

He said this could be seen time and again on tests carried out on Millbrook’s chassis dynamometer. “Obviously one person taking a set of golf clubs out of his boot when they’re not required isn’t going to make much difference to his fuel use. However, if everyone in the country did it, it would make a impact in terms of protecting the environment.”




Results at a glance

30.5mpg – Astra’s baseline fuel economy
30.4mpg – Two front windows a third open
30.3mpg – Roof bars and laden roofbox
30.2mpg – Two front windows totally open
29.7mpg – Four tyres down to 20psi
28.0mpg – Air-conditioning on
27.2mpg – Three large adult males in the back seat
24.1mpg – Roof bars and laden roofbox, plus three adults in the rear, a bike carrier with two adult bikes and air-con




Eco driving: The main facts

- Air-conditioning makes a big difference when driving at low speeds, but has very little impact on the motorway.
- Having the windows up or down makes very little difference.
- A modern aerodynamic roofbox barely impacts on fuel used.
- Slowing down on the motorway will boost fuel economy dramatically.
_________________________
Autowirral.co.uk - The Northwest's Biggest forum of Motoring Enthusiasts.
Cruisewirral.com - The Northwest's Biggest forum of Modified Car Enthusiasts.

Top
AutoWirral : Advertising
Click me for more Information......

* * * Julie : LED Lights Supplied and Fitted Free * * *
Now Advertise with WikiWirral.
WikiWirral stats 35,000 Page Views a Day +500 Search Engines.. Click Me
#266529 - 28th Oct 2008 1:33pm Re: The mpg mythbusters [Re: BMW Joe]
StuyMac Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 24th Nov 2003
Posts: 12002
Loc: Wirralshire
Interesting figures there.. think
_________________________


What If There Were No Hypothetical Questions?

Top
#266531 - 28th Oct 2008 1:34pm Re: The mpg mythbusters [Re: StuyMac]
MGCraig Offline
AlfaHolic
Forum Veteran

Registered: 16th Apr 2006
Posts: 5488
Loc: Spital
Im amazed that a 1.9 Diesel Astra only does 30 mpg !!

Surely that cant be right??
_________________________


------------------------------------------------------------

Top
#266533 - 28th Oct 2008 1:41pm Re: The mpg mythbusters [Re: MGCraig]
StuyMac Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 24th Nov 2003
Posts: 12002
Loc: Wirralshire
Thinking about it that is quite surprising.

Las t hire car I had was a 1.9 CDTi Vectra ( sick ) and that averaged mid 50's on a 600mile round trip...
_________________________


What If There Were No Hypothetical Questions?

Top
#266617 - 28th Oct 2008 7:44pm Re: The mpg mythbusters [Re: StuyMac]
Dave100e Offline

Veteran

Registered: 14th Jul 2008
Posts: 690
Loc: Greasby
My Dads 2.0 cdti vectra only ever averaged high 30's to low 40's, his new avensis petrol does that.
_________________________
I HATE cars.

Top
#266627 - 28th Oct 2008 8:45pm Re: The mpg mythbusters [Re: Dave100e]
MattLFC Offline
Wiki Master

Registered: 14th Aug 2004
Posts: 22315
Loc: Moreton/Beirut/Mobile
Higher speeds on the motorways is deffo a no-no for economical driving.

I do 60ish on the motorway usually, as it much more efficient (not to mention a bit safer) than 70.

Even my owners manual states my MPG at 56mph is 70 whereas at 70mph it is reduced to a miserly 52!!

Top
#266630 - 28th Oct 2008 8:56pm Re: The mpg mythbusters [Re: MattLFC]
StuyMac Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 24th Nov 2003
Posts: 12002
Loc: Wirralshire
The trip computer on the BMW hasnt been reset for nearly 1000miles now. Granted, my daily commute is about 100 miles (all motorway) sticking to 70 on the cruise control, but the trip computer is showing 47.8mpg average (inc round town driving) - not bad for a 3.0 omg
_________________________


What If There Were No Hypothetical Questions?

Top
#266737 - 29th Oct 2008 9:27am Re: The mpg mythbusters [Re: StuyMac]
chris bmw M3 Offline
Smartchild

Registered: 8th Mar 2005
Posts: 410
Loc: Bidston
Good figures there Stu...think I will have to get one..My 540i is currently doin 13.9mpg!! (on gas)

I think the Astra in the test will have been redlined in every gear upto the required speed as to give an accurate and easily obtainable comparison between runs(hence low figures)

Top
#266740 - 29th Oct 2008 9:45am Re: The mpg mythbusters [Re: chris bmw M3]
StuyMac Offline

Wiki Master

Registered: 24th Nov 2003
Posts: 12002
Loc: Wirralshire
Hmmm, V8-ness though grin
_________________________


What If There Were No Hypothetical Questions?

Top

Moderator:  StuyMac 
Random Wirral Images

Click to View Topic.
Newest Topics
Name help
by Paternoster21
08:03 AM
HMT Lancastria
by granny
11:38 PM
Wirral Globe
by locomotive
1st Dec 2016 6:25pm
54 plate renault clio 3rd brake light
by Mike72
1st Dec 2016 12:52pm
Raspberry Pi in the classroom!
by FelixCowden
30th Nov 2016 9:27pm
For Sale & Free
Steam Train Money Box/Ornaments
by Tranquil
1st Dec 2016 11:32am
Childs LFC Bike 5 - 8 Yr old
by Pete_M
1st Dec 2016 1:10am
Cat related Collectables
by Tranquil
29th Nov 2016 4:48pm
original xbox
by vw_kyle
27th Nov 2016 8:17pm
anything with castors
by lincle
27th Nov 2016 4:06pm
Featured Member
Registered: 4th Apr 2010
Posts: 39533
Newest Members
uptonvillage, NobbyHunt, sam1512, ant72, benjamin17
12131 Registered Users
Today's Birthdays
No Birthdays
New Wirral Info
Wirral Globe
by locomotive
1st Dec 2016 6:25pm
Wirral TUC Meeting re Update on Wallasey CLP Suspe
by RUDEBOX
30th Nov 2016 9:16pm
World Aids Day Event 2016. Liverpool
by RUDEBOX
30th Nov 2016 9:05pm
A job. Company not named.
by venice
30th Nov 2016 6:30pm
Santa's Grotto at Tam O'Shanter 11th Dec.
by Greenwood
29th Nov 2016 1:44pm
News : New Topics
Pensby Hotel
by granny
29th Nov 2016 6:39pm
Paul Nuttall Elected UKIP leader
by granny
28th Nov 2016 12:03pm
Disgusting surely not legal creamfields noise !!@
by svenlock68
27th Nov 2016 8:25am
Paying for EU Citizenship (Poll)
by diggingdeeper
26th Nov 2016 12:35pm
Footballers--Abused
by fish5133
25th Nov 2016 3:46pm
New Enthusiast Forums
54 plate renault clio 3rd brake light
by Mike72
1st Dec 2016 12:52pm
Raspberry Pi in the classroom!
by FelixCowden
30th Nov 2016 9:27pm
crop loss & water rationing in Dominican Republic
by FelixCowden
30th Nov 2016 8:46pm
PC Repair needed
by TudorBlue
29th Nov 2016 2:54pm
Sports Personality Of The Year
by fish5133
29th Nov 2016 12:32am
(Views 24hrs)Trending Newest Topics
HMT Lancastria 178
Name help 124
Daft funny joke 28
Lib/dems rule the day 28
Wirral Sunrise Sunset
Sunrise Sat 8:09am
Sunset Sat 3:55pm
Local Time Sat 3:36pm
WikiWirral Can . . . .