As Wally suggests, it probably did depend on the dairy,
Attachments: Viewing Permissions May Apply. Click Me
However, snippets from various newspapers from many areas, 1938/39 report on Aluminium and foil milk bottle tops being collected for charitable causes.
A report from 1942, Daily Post, suggests the milkman would collect Aluminium tops but not the cardboard tops.
God help us,
Don't send Jesus,
This is no place for children.